With more than a third, or roughly 36% of all Brits already investing, the allure of growing wealth is undeniable. However, many feel hesitant, citing a lack of knowledge as a barrier. Enter Moneybox and Moneyfarm, two popular investment platforms in the UK.
Unsure which one to choose? Our guide simplifies the decision-making process so you can confidently decide which way to go.
|
Great All Round Money Management App
|
Best Robo-Advisor
|
|
4.0
|
4.0
|
|
Description: Moneybox is a financial platform offering multiple finance products such as savings, investments, pensions, and even mortgage advice services. They have promising returns in their risk-based portfolios and offer reasonable fees. |
Description: Moneyfarm is one of the UK's premier digital wealth managers, dedicated to simplifying investments and helping individuals grow their assets. Providing innovative investment solutions, Moneyfarm focuses on delivering tailor-made portfolios based on individual risk appetites and financial goals. |
|
Pros:
|
Pros:
|
|
Cons:
|
Cons:
|
Moneybox is a financial platform offering multiple finance products such as savings, investments, pensions, and even mortgage advice services. They have promising returns in their risk-based portfolios and offer reasonable fees.
- - Wide range of financial products
- - Great returns on their pre-built portfolios
- - Great customer support
- - Free Mortgage advice
- - Only 20 stocks available
- - £1 Monthly Subscription
Moneyfarm is one of the UK's premier digital wealth managers, dedicated to simplifying investments and helping individuals grow their assets. Providing innovative investment solutions, Moneyfarm focuses on delivering tailor-made portfolios based on individual risk appetites and financial goals.
- Slick easy to use app
- Great for passive investors
- High fees on certain products
- Poor returns on low risk funds
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm Overview
Investment platforms like Moneybox and Moneyfarm offer accessible avenues for individuals to invest their funds. Investing starts with minimal amounts, and users can manage their portfolios easily with user-friendly interfaces and proactive budgeting features.
These platforms typically provide diverse investment options, personalized portfolio recommendations, and regulatory oversight to ensure security and compliance.
Moneybox
Moneybox is a versatile platform that caters to savings, investments, and pensions, requiring just a minimum of £1 to get started. It serves as an all-in-one solution for managing finances, offering reasonable interest rates and high-performing pre-built portfolios.
This app is particularly beneficial for newcomers looking to enhance their financial management skills. With an easy-to-use interface, Moneybox seamlessly connects to your bank account, facilitating savings and providing opportunities to transition from saving to investing.
Moneyfarm
Positioned as one of the UK’s premier digital wealth managers, Moneyfarm specializes in simplifying investments to help individuals grow their assets.
Moneyfarm focuses on providing customized investment solutions and crafting portfolios based on individual risk preferences and financial objectives. This platform offers a range of investment options, from pre-selected portfolios ideal for beginners to customizable funds for those seeking more active management of their investments.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm Comparison
| Platform | Moneybox | Moneyfarm |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4 | 4 |
| Minimum Investment | £1 | £500 |
| Products Available | – General Investment Account – Junior ISA – Lifetime ISA – PensionSavings Accounts | – General Investment Account – ISA – Junior ISA – Pension |
| Investment Options | – Pre-Made Portfolios – Custom Portfolio – Individual Stocks – Socially Responsible Investing | – Fixed Allocation – Active Management – Thematic – ESG (Socially Responsible) |
| Fees | £1 monthly subscription (free for the first 3 months) Platform Fee: 0.45%Fund Fees: 0.12% to 0.58% (Set by the fund) | Platform Fee: starts at £500 (0.75% for actively managed; 0.45% for fixed allocation Investment Fund Fees: 0.2% for actively managed; 0.15% for fixed allocationMarket Spread Fees: Up to 0.9% for actively managed; 0.02% for fixed allocation |
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Getting Started
Embarking on your investment journey is easier than ever with platforms like Moneybox and Moneyfarm.
Moneybox
Investing with Moneybox is incredibly accessible, requiring just £1 to get started. The app’s user-friendly interface simplifies fund management, and its proactive budgeting features help users identify potential savings for investment.
Signing up for Moneybox is quick and straightforward through the phone, requiring only basic personal and banking information, and can be completed within minutes.
Moneyfarm
On the other hand, Moneyfarm requires a £500 minimum investment but offers a robust platform for asset growth. It adopts a wealth manager approach, optimizing investments within users’ budgets.
Registration is also straightforward both on its app and website, involving a risk assessment so the robo-advisor can determine the most suitable portfolio. Once completed, users can open their preferred product and initiate investments.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Products
When it comes to investing and saving for the future, Moneybox and Moneyfarm offer a range of products tailored to meet your financial goals.
Moneybox
Moneybox provides a comprehensive suite of investment and savings products designed to help you grow your wealth and plan for the future.
- General Investment Account: Start investing from as little as £1. While there are no tax benefits, you have the flexibility to buy and sell ETFs and stocks according to your preferences.
- Junior ISA: Invest up to £9,000 annually in your child’s future. This tax-efficient account allows your child to access the funds once they turn 18, whether it’s for their first car, house deposit, or university expenses.
- Lifetime ISA: Offers both cash and Stocks and Shares Lifetime ISAs, each with its unique benefits. Save up to £4,000 per year and receive a 25% government bonus. Choose between a Stocks and Shares option for investment growth or a Cash LISA for guaranteed interest earnings.
- Pension: Take control of your pension savings. Consolidate your old workplace pensions into one convenient account and continue saving and investing for retirement with ease.
- Savings Accounts: Moneybox also offers a range of savings accounts, including simple savers and notice accounts with 32, 45, 95, and 120-day notice accounts, providing flexibility and options to suit your savings needs.
Moneyfarm
Moneyfarm simplifies investing with its range of products designed to help you achieve your financial goals efficiently.
- General Investment Account: While there are no tax benefits, you have the freedom to buy and sell shares according to your investment strategy.
- ISA: Benefit from tax-efficient investing with Moneyfarm’s ISA, allowing you to invest up to £20,000 annually without paying tax on profits or withdrawals. Enjoy tax-free capital gains, income, and dividends on your investments.
- Junior ISA: As with Moneybox, you can secure your child’s future by investing up to £9,000 annually. The funds become accessible to your child once they reach adulthood.
- Pension: Take advantage of Moneyfarm’s pension management services through a Self Invested Personal Pension (SIPP). Benefit from government bonuses on pension contributions and manage your pension investments according to your preferences and risk appetite.
Whether you’re saving for retirement, your child’s future, or simply growing your investment portfolio, these platforms provide the tools and support you need to achieve your goals with confidence.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Investment Options
Choosing how to invest your money comes next after deciding which investment account to use.
Moneybox
Moneybox stands out with its flexible investment options.
- Pre-Made Portfolios: Offers 3 pre-made portfolios tailored to different risk tolerances, each including a global shares fund and other assets to adjust risk. Socially responsible versions are available.
- Custom Portfolio: Investors can build their own portfolio from 24 available funds covering various sectors and regions.
- Individual Stocks: Provides a selection of US stocks, purchasable as fractional shares, ideal for diversification even with a small portfolio. Currently, they offer 20 stocks on their platform.
Moneyfarm
On the other hand, Moneyfarm offers a choice between two management styles.
- Fixed Allocation: Portfolios are initially set up by experts and require minimal intervention, with only one annual rebalance. Emphasizes passive growth.
- Active Management: Portfolios are continuously monitored and adjusted to seize market opportunities and manage risks effectively.
Within each management style, investors can select from a range of risk options, from low to high, each offering different growth potential and volatility levels.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Portfolio Performance
Moneybox and Moneyfarm offer distinct approaches with varying outcomes.
Moneybox offers a trio of preset portfolios consistently outperforming competitors like Moneyfarm. Their Low portfolio exhibits an impressive 10.5% 5-year return, while Medium and High portfolios soar even higher, boasting 34.5% and 40.5% returns respectively over the same period.
| Risk Level | Moneybox 5 Year Returns (Total) | Moneybox 5 Year Return (Yearly Avg) |
|---|---|---|
| Low | 10.5% | 2.02% |
| Medium | 34.5% | 6.1% |
| High | 40.5% | 7.04% |
In contrast, Moneyfarm’s low-risk funds have faced challenges, with one even yielding negative returns. Their Low portfolio showcases a -7.1% 5-year return, while Medium and High portfolios present returns of 10.6% and 25.5% respectively.
| Risk Level | Moneyfarm 5 Year Returns (Total) | Moneyfarm 5 Year Return (Yearly Avg) |
|---|---|---|
| Low | -7.1% | -1.5% |
| Medium | 10.6% | 2.1% |
| High | 25.5% | 4.7% |
Taking a five-year look through December 2022, we find that Moneybox clearly takes the lead over Moneyfarm by a large margin. Particularly noteworthy is that Moneybox’s low-risk portfolio was the only one to make positive returns during this period.
Moneybox primarily invests in a single Index World Fund from Fidelity, known as Global Shares. This fund gives investors broad exposure to the global stock market at a low cost. They adjust the allocation of these holdings based on how much risk the investor is willing to take. This straightforward approach ensures that investments are well-diversified and managed to minimize risks.
On the other hand, Moneyfarm is geared towards investors who prefer a hands-off approach. They offer higher-risk funds for those who want to invest passively. However, even Moneyfarm’s riskiest portfolio maintains a conservative strategy, showing their preference for cautious investing.
Both Moneybox and Moneyfarm provide options for investing, but they differ in their investment performance and portfolio structures. This gives investors a range of choices tailored to their preferences and risk tolerance levels.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Fees
Take a look at how the fees for both platforms stack up.
Moneybox
Moneybox adopts a diverse fee structure across its range of products.
- Savings & Cash Lifetime ISAs: Moneybox imposes zero fees on all savings accounts and Cash Lifetime ISAs.
- Investment Account Fees: Opening an investment account with Moneybox incurs three types of fees. You’ll encounter a fixed monthly subscription fee of £1, platform fees of 0.45%, and additional underlying fund fees. Investing in individual stocks may also entail currency conversion fees.
- Pension Fees: Moneybox’s pension scheme, on the other hand, operates without a monthly subscription fee. Instead, it employs tiered fees based on your pension’s size. The annual platform fee is 0.45% for pensions up to £100k, and 0.15% for amounts exceeding £100k.
Moneyfarm
Investing with Moneyfarm involves navigating three distinct types of fees: Moneyfarm Platform Fee + Underlying Fund Fee + Market Spread.
- Platform Fee: Moneyfarm levies platform fees based on the amount invested, starting at £500 with a 0.75% fee for actively managed accounts and a 0.45% fee for fixed allocation accounts.
- Investment Fund Fees: Underlying fund fees average around 0.2% for actively managed funds and 0.15% for fixed allocation funds.
- Market Spread Fees: Essentially transaction costs, these vary depending on the type of account. Actively managed accounts may face fees up to 0.9%, while fixed allocation accounts experience lower fees of around 0.02%.
Both platforms employ different fee structures tailored to their respective products. Consider your investment preferences and budgetary constraints when choosing between these platforms.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Reviews
When it comes to customer feedback, both Moneybox and Moneyfarm have their own story to tell. Moneybox shines with an impressive Trustpilot score of 4.6 stars, earning praise from 78% of users with over 1,500 reviews. Conversely, Moneyfarm maintains a respectable 3.8-star rating, with 68% of users awarding it 5 stars.
The App Store reviews give both platforms high ratings, but Moneybox excels because of the staggering number of ratings while remaining remarkably well-regarded.
| Platform | Trustpilot | App Store | Money Sprout Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moneybox | 4.6 | 4.8 (44.7k ratings) | 4 |
| Moneyfarm | 3.8 | 4.6 (1.7k ratings) | 4 |
Users praise Moneybox for its seamless saving solutions and helpful team, while Moneyfarm’s user-friendly app receives positive feedback despite concerns about fund performance, especially with lower-risk options.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Customer Support
Both Moneybox and Moneyfarm provide exceptional customer support and prioritize financial education. Moneybox offers robust assistance through its support system and features an extensive FAQ section and Learn Hub.
Similarly, Moneyfarm offers 24/7 support via live chat, phone, and email, along with educational resources on its Insights page and downloadable ebooks.
Moneybox vs Moneyfarm: Safety
Both Moneybox and Moneyfarm are regulated by the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), ensuring compliance with industry standards and regulations.
The two platforms focus on user security, implementing bank-level security measures and robust login protocols to safeguard user information.
Furthermore, users’ funds are protected under the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS), offering peace of mind in the event of bankruptcy or financial fraud. In such cases, up to £85,000 of users’ funds are fully protected.
Which Investment Platform is Right for You?
Choosing between Moneybox and Moneyfarm ultimately depends on your individual financial goals, preferences, and investment strategy.
Moneybox is ideal for beginners or those seeking a user-friendly platform with low investment requirements and proactive budgeting features. Meanwhile, Moneyfarm is ideal for investors looking for a wealth management approach, with personalized portfolio options and a focus on optimizing existing investments.
Consider factors like investment minimums, fees, customer support, safety measures, and available products to make your decision. Ultimately, choose the platform that aligns best with your investment objectives and risk tolerance.
Read More From Moneysprout:
